A Deep Dive Into the New High Impact Player Rule

Tragedy Strikes As Valencia Coach Found Dead With His Kids

Welcome to this week’s edition of Goalside Gossip!

With no NWSL matches to report on this week, the news cycle is all about off-field drama, record-breaking moves, and heartbreaking headlines. First up, the league officially unveiled its new “High-Impact Player” rule, allowing teams to go $1 million over the salary cap for elite talent, a move already sparking speculation over who’s in, who’s out, and how clubs might maneuver to lock down stars like Trinity Rodman.

Meanwhile, Alabama standout Gianna Paul keeps turning heads, signing with Kansas City and aiming to carry her record-breaking college form into the professional ranks. Denver Summit FC is also making waves, smashing transfer records before the club even kicks off its inaugural season.

Off the field, tragedy struck internationally as Spanish coach Fernando Martín and his three children were found dead following a boat sinking near Indonesia’s Komodo National Park, a somber reminder of life beyond the pitch. In short: no goals, no lineups, just news, records, and heartbreak.

  • Updates this week:

    • News: A Deep Dive Into the New NWSL “High Impact Rule”

    • News: Alabama Star Looks to Keep Breaking Records in the NWSL

    • News: Tragedy in Indonesia as Coach and Kids Found Dead

    • News: Denver Breaking Records Already

A Deep Dive Into the New
“High Impact Player” Rule

Stars like Trinity Rodman could choose to stay in the states as a result of this new rule

The NWSL’s new High-Impact Player Rule, effective July 1, allows clubs to exceed the salary cap by up to $1 million for one player who meets specific eligibility criteria. Rather than simply raising the cap across the board (which the players’ union preferred), the league created a tightly defined mechanism designed to retain elite players and attract global stars. A player only needs to meet one of seven benchmarks, including top international rankings, national team minutes, or recent league honors, to qualify.

The rule naturally benefits the league’s most decorated and visible stars, including Trinity Rodman, Marta, Lindsey Heaps, and Sophia Wilson, many of whom qualify under multiple categories. It also allows top international talent like Aitana Bonmatí and Khadija Shaw to be brought into or retained in the NWSL. However, the system has clear limitations: some of the game’s biggest names and rising stars are excluded because they lack recent minutes, rankings, or awards due to injury, maternity leave timing, or simply not appearing on media lists.

As a result, while the rule represents a meaningful step toward modernizing the NWSL’s financial structure, it also exposes tension between rigid criteria and soccer reality. High-profile players like Catarina Macario, Sam Kerr, Lizbeth Ovalle, and emerging U.S. talents such as Lily Yohannes and Alyssa Thompson are currently ineligible, not due to lack of quality, but because the system prioritizes recent visibility over long-term value. The rule is a powerful tool, but one that may need refinement to better reflect how elite talent actually develops and moves within the global game.

High-Impact Rule Eligibility Criteria

#

Eligibility Requirement

1

Top 150 Most Marketable Athletes (SportsPro) within past year

2

Top 30 in Ballon d’Or voting in last 2 years

3

Top 40 in Guardian Top 100 in last 2 years

4

Top 40 in ESPN FC Top 50 in last 2 years

5

Top 11 in USWNT minutes (field players) over last 2 years

6

Top USWNT goalkeeper minutes over last 2 years

7

NWSL MVP finalist or Best XI First Team in last 2 seasons

A player only needs to meet one of these to qualify.

Players Eligible in 5–7 Categories

Player

Club

Nation

Barbra Banda

Orlando Pride

Zambia

Temwa Chawinga

Kansas City

Malawi

Esther González

Gotham FC

Spain

Lindsey Heaps

OL Lyonnes

USA

Marta

Orlando Pride

Brazil

Trinity Rodman

Free Agent

USA

Sophia Wilson

Portland Thorns

USA

Players Eligible in 3–4 Categories (Selected)

Player

Club

Nation

Aitana Bonmatí

Barcelona

Spain

Naomi Girma

Chelsea

USA

Sam Coffey

Portland Thorns

USA

Mallory Swanson

Chicago Stars

USA

Khadija Shaw

Manchester City

Jamaica

Alexia Putellas

Barcelona

Spain

Caroline Graham Hansen

Barcelona

Norway

Melchie Dumornay

OL Lyonnes

Haiti

Lauren James

Chelsea

England

Alyssa Naeher

Chicago Stars

USA (ret.)

Players Eligible in 1–2 Categories (Selected)

Player

Club

Nation

Rose Lavelle

Gotham FC

USA

Tierna Davidson

Gotham FC

USA

Linda Caicedo

Real Madrid

Colombia

Ada Hegerberg

OL Lyonnes

Norway

Olivia Moultrie

Portland Thorns

USA

Beth Mead

Arsenal

England

Mary Earps

PSG

England (ret.)

Katie McCabe

Arsenal

Ireland

Crystal Dunn

PSG

USA

Notably Not Eligible

Player

Reason

Catarina Macario

Missed criteria due to long ACL recovery

Sam Kerr

Injured and absent from recent rankings/minutes

Lizbeth Ovalle

No qualifying rankings despite record transfer

Lily Yohannes

Too young / not yet ranked

Alyssa Thompson

Lacks qualifying benchmarks

Phallon Tullis-Joyce

Goalkeeper rule favors only one candidate

Bottom line:

The rule gives the NWSL a powerful lever to retain global stars, but its narrow, metrics-driven design risks excluding exactly the kind of elite and emerging talent the league wants to attract.

From Bama to KC
Gianna Paul Has Big Dreams

Paul is looking to bring his explosive prowess to an already good KC Current team

Gianna Paul, one of the most decorated players in Alabama women’s soccer history, has signed a three-year professional contract with the NWSL’s Kansas City Current, becoming the ninth Crimson Tide alum to reach the league. With the NWSL no longer holding a draft under its current CBA, Paul’s direct signing underscores her readiness for the professional level and the high regard in which she’s held. Her move closes a historic college chapter and opens what many see as a highly promising pro career.

Paul leaves Alabama as the program’s first two-time All-American and its all-time leader in goals (40) and points (94), rewriting records that had stood for nearly two decades. Known for her consistency and attacking output, she also set school marks for career shots, shots on goal, and single-season shots, while ranking among the nation’s top active Division I players in goals and points by the end of her collegiate career.

Beyond the statistics and awards, Paul’s legacy is defined by how she elevated the standard of Alabama soccer, helping shift perceptions of what the program could achieve nationally. Now with Kansas City, she brings that same competitiveness and scoring edge to the NWSL, where expectations for her impact are already high.

Tragedy in Indonesia as Coach
And Kids Found Dead

Fernando Martín and his three young kids sadly passed away Friday evening in Indonesia

A tour boat carrying a Spanish family and crew sank Friday evening near Padar Island in Indonesia’s Komodo National Park after suffering engine failure, prompting a large-scale search-and-rescue operation. Of the 11 people onboard, including six family members, four crew and a local guide, seven were rescued, among them the Spanish mother and one daughter. The father and three children were initially reported missing, as rough seas, darkness and poor visibility hampered overnight rescue efforts.

Spanish club Valencia later confirmed that the missing father was Fernando Martín, a coach for its women’s reserve team, and that he and his three children, aged 12, 10 and 9, had died, according to local authorities. Real Madrid and Valencia both issued public statements expressing shock and condolences to Martín’s wife, Andrea, and surviving daughter, Mar, as well as to the broader football community affected by the tragedy.

Search operations were temporarily suspended due to bad weather but are set to resume, with Indonesian rescue teams, navy divers, and local fishermen involved in the effort across a five-nautical-mile radius around the wreck site. The incident highlights ongoing maritime safety challenges in Indonesia’s vast archipelago, where boats are a primary mode of transport and accidents remain common due to overcrowding and inconsistent safety standards.

Denver Breaking
Records Already

Oke looks to be the next star in the NWSL

Denver Summit FC has agreed to sign U.S. defender Ayo Oke from Mexico’s Pachuca for a fee close to $450,000, which would be the highest incoming transfer fee ever paid for an American player in NWSL history and among the largest overall league transfers. The 22-year-old U.S. youth international played college soccer at Cal and UCLA before joining Pachuca in January 2025, where she won the Clausura title and helped the club finish second in the Apertura regular season. Oke has recently featured in U.S. U23 camps and will now anchor a developing Denver roster as the expansion club prepares for its inaugural 2026 season.

The move highlights both Denver’s ambition and the NWSL’s broader effort to compete globally for top talent as it retools salary and roster rules. While intra-league transfers like Jaedyn Shaw’s $1.25 million move to Gotham still dwarf this fee, Denver’s willingness to pay a major sum for a young American abroad reflects the league’s changing economics and growing market sophistication.

Oke’s transfer fits into a rapidly escalating global women’s transfer market that has seen record deals in recent years, including Orlando’s $1.5 million acquisition of Jacqui Ovalle and Bay FC’s record-setting move for Racheal Kundananji. As fees continue to rise for both young prospects and established stars, Denver’s investment in Oke signals that expansion clubs are entering the league prepared to compete financially and sporting-wise from day one.

Enjoying Goalside Gossip? Forward this edition to a friend who may like it!

New here? Subscribe for free at www.goalsidegossip.com—your inbox will thank you.